Executive Summary / Key Takeaways

• Strategic Specialization Driving Growth: Metallus Inc. is successfully transforming into a high-value specialty metals producer, with a strong focus on the burgeoning Aerospace & Defense (A&D) market, targeting an annual sales run rate exceeding $250 million by mid-2026.
• Robust Financial Health and Shareholder Returns: The company boasts a strong balance sheet, achieving debt-free status in Q2 2025, and actively returns capital to shareholders through a significant share repurchase program that has reduced diluted shares outstanding by 25% since late 2021.
• Operational Excellence and Technological Edge: Ongoing investments in advanced manufacturing technologies, such as the automated grinding line and government-funded furnaces, are enhancing efficiency and throughput, complemented by a focus on high-performance materials like Vacuum Arc Remelt (VAR) steel.
• Beneficiary of Favorable Trade Environment: Increased steel tariffs are creating a more level playing field, boosting demand for domestically produced steel and leading to new customer engagements and market share gains for Metallus.
• Positive Outlook Despite Near-Term Headwinds: While Q4 2025 faces seasonal and operational challenges, management anticipates a stronger 2026, driven by A&D expansion, new energy programs, and the full realization of efficiency initiatives.

A Specialized Foundation in a Resurgent Steel Market

Metallus Inc., formerly TimkenSteel Corporation, has strategically repositioned itself as a premier U.S. producer of high-performance specialty metals. Founded in 1899, the Canton, Ohio-based company leverages electric arc furnace (EAF) technology to manufacture alloy, carbon, and micro-alloy steel products. Its portfolio includes special bar quality (SBQ) bars, seamless mechanical tubing, precision steel components, and billets, serving demanding applications across industrial, automotive, aerospace & defense, and energy end-markets. This specialization, particularly in high-value segments, forms the bedrock of its investment thesis.

The broader steel industry is experiencing a resurgence, driven by a favorable trade environment. Recent U.S. government actions, including a minimum 50% tariff on steel long products and efforts to close loopholes in existing tariffs, are leveling the playing field and stimulating demand for domestically produced steel. This shift is a significant tailwind for Metallus, as customers increasingly prioritize secure and stable domestic supply chains. The company has observed a meaningful increase in customer engagement and inquiries for 2026, with its order backlog doubling year-over-year by Q2 2025.

Technological Edge and Operational Excellence

Metallus's competitive advantage is deeply rooted in its technological differentiation and commitment to operational excellence. The company's EAF technology allows for flexible and efficient production of specialized alloys. Its expertise extends to manufacturing SBQ bars and seamless mechanical tubing, products critical for applications requiring high strength and durability.

A key differentiator is Metallus's growing participation in Vacuum Arc Remelt (VAR) and Vacuum Induction Melt (VIM) steel. These advanced materials offer enhanced strength and durability, making them ideal for critical aerospace, defense, and industrial applications. Metallus has strategically positioned itself to procure, engineer, process, and sell these VAR products efficiently, having executed a long-term supply agreement with a trusted partner. VAR-related sales more than doubled in the first half of 2025 compared to the first half of 2024, and the company is on track to achieve approximately $30 million in VAR-related revenue by the end of 2025. This focus on high-performance materials provides a significant competitive moat, allowing Metallus to offer superior product performance in niche applications, particularly against competitors focused on more generalized steel production.

Beyond material science, Metallus is investing heavily in manufacturing automation and efficiency. The $18 million automated grinding line at its Harrison facility, commissioned in Q2 2025, is expected to generate over $3 million in annual savings by improving safety and throughput. Furthermore, an initiative launched in July 2025, involving external resources to optimize day-to-day manufacturing operations, is projected to yield approximately $10 million in annual savings, with benefits ramping up throughout the first half of 2026. These investments and initiatives underscore a strategic drive to reduce costs and enhance profitability through advanced manufacturing techniques.

Financial Performance Reflecting Strategic Momentum

Metallus has demonstrated consistent financial improvement, particularly in recent quarters. For the third quarter of 2025, net sales reached $305.9 million, a substantial 34.6% increase from $227.2 million in Q3 2024. This growth was primarily fueled by a $63.9 million increase from higher shipment volumes and an $18.8 million boost from favorable surcharges, partially offset by a $4 million impact from unfavorable price/mix. Adjusted EBITDA for Q3 2025 rose to $29 million, marking the fourth consecutive quarter of sequential growth and reflecting improved product mix and melt utilization.

Year-to-date through September 30, 2025, net sales increased 5.6% to $891 million, up from $843.5 million in the same period of 2024. Gross profit for the nine months ended September 30, 2025, also saw a modest increase to $89.1 million, compared to $86.8 million in the prior year. This was driven by higher volume, favorable raw material spread, and improved manufacturing performance, despite some unfavorable price/mix. The company reported net income of $8.1 million ($0.19 diluted EPS) for Q3 2025, and $13.1 million ($0.30 diluted EPS) for the nine months ended September 30, 2025.

Metallus maintains a robust financial position. As of September 30, 2025, total liquidity stood at $436.9 million, including $191.5 million in cash and cash equivalents. A significant financial milestone was achieved in Q2 2025 when the company became debt-free after settling its remaining convertible notes.

Operating cash flow for Q3 2025 was $22 million, contributing to $17.9 million for the nine-month period. Capital expenditures for the full year 2025 are projected to be approximately $120 million, with a substantial $90 million funded by the U.S. government, primarily for strategic A&D projects. The company also actively returns capital to shareholders, repurchasing 0.20 million common shares for $3 million in Q3 2025, with $90.9 million remaining under its authorization. These actions have collectively reduced diluted shares outstanding by 25% since Q4 2021.

Strategic Growth Pillars and Market Dynamics

Metallus's growth narrative is strongly tied to its performance in key end-markets:

Aerospace & Defense (A&D) Expansion

The A&D sector is a primary growth engine. Metallus's backlog in A&D is up approximately 80% year-over-year. The company is actively gaining traction in new and existing programs, including specialty bar and tubing for munitions, gun barrels, aerospace bearings, warheads, and rocket motor casings. A significant $99.75 million funding agreement with the U.S. Army supports the installation of a continuous bloom reheat furnace (expected operational late 2025) and a roller hearth heat treat furnace (expected operational H1 2026), both designed to increase munitions production. Metallus aims to achieve an A&D sales run rate exceeding $250 million by mid-2026. This aggressive expansion, supported by government investment and specialized products like VAR steel, positions Metallus as a critical supplier in a high-growth, national security-driven market.

Automotive Sector Resilience

Despite broader industry shifts, Metallus's automotive shipments increased slightly sequentially in Q3 2025, driven by solid demand in light truck and SUV programs. The company targets approximately 40% of its shipments to the automotive sector in 2025, benefiting from market share gains and increased customer inquiries related to tariff-driven onshoring. Its participation across internal combustion, hybrid, and electric vehicle platforms provides a hedge against market volatility.

Energy Market Rebound

After reduced volumes, the energy market is showing signs of a rebound for Metallus. Shipments increased 49% year-over-year in Q3 2025. With declining import levels and tightened tariff enforcement, the company is capturing greater customer share for 2026. New programs, including seamless mechanical tubing for offshore well tieback casings and high-pressure tubes for petrochemical LDPE reactors, are targeted to generate $20 million in annual sales starting in 2026. The high-pressure tubes are notably "one of the very few globally qualified materials for this critical component," highlighting Metallus's specialized capabilities.

Industrial Sector Stability

Industrial shipments, while experiencing some sequential decrease in Q3 2025, are showing signs of strengthening for 2026, with customers projecting stronger forecasts. The company has seen increased order activity from distributors restocking inventories, indicating a healthier demand environment.

`

Competitive Landscape and Strategic Positioning

Metallus operates in a competitive steel market, facing large diversified players like Nucor Corporation , Steel Dynamics, Inc. , and ArcelorMittal , as well as specialty alloy producers like Carpenter Technology Corporation . Metallus distinguishes itself as a niche player, focusing on high-value, custom products for demanding applications, positioning it as a leader in precision engineering rather than a broad-market commodity producer.

Compared to Nucor (NUE) and Steel Dynamics (STLD), which benefit from scale and cost leadership in broader steel production, Metallus's strength lies in its specialized product performance. For instance, its micro-alloy steels and billets offer significantly greater performance in high-stress energy environments than more generalized offerings. Similarly, its SBQ bars provide notably better performance for specific applications like heavy truck components compared to ArcelorMittal's (MT) wider portfolio. While these larger competitors may exhibit stronger growth rates and cash flow due to their diversified operations and global reach, Metallus's focus on advanced alloys and proprietary processes allows for superior product performance and customer loyalty in its targeted segments.

Against Carpenter Technology (CRS), a fellow specialty producer, Metallus's seamless tubes offer comparable performance in aerospace, but its historical expertise and custom manufacturing provide significantly greater reliability in energy sector products. Metallus's established distribution and customer relationships, particularly in the U.S., enhance its capital efficiency and foster long-term contracts, providing stable revenue streams and reducing vulnerability to price wars. However, its smaller global scale can lead to higher operational costs compared to multinational rivals. Indirect competitors, such as advanced composites and 3D-printed metals, pose a long-term threat by offering alternative materials, which could impact demand for steel in certain applications.

Outlook and Forward Guidance

Metallus's management anticipates a dynamic period ahead. For the fourth quarter of 2025, adjusted EBITDA is expected to be lower than Q3 2025, primarily due to normal year-end seasonality, increased planned annual shutdown maintenance costs of approximately $11 million (an $8 million sequential increase), and potential global supply chain challenges impacting customer production. Shipments are projected to be 5% to 10% lower sequentially, and product mix is expected to be less favorable. However, base price per ton is anticipated to increase slightly due to previously announced 5% bar and tube price increases. Despite these near-term headwinds, Q4 2025 adjusted EBITDA is expected to improve slightly compared to Q4 2024.

Looking further into 2026, the outlook is more optimistic. Management is confident in securing approximately 70% of its long products business through annual agreements, with encouraging customer conversations indicating increased volumes. The full realization of operational efficiency initiatives, expected to ramp up throughout the first half of 2026, will contribute to annual savings of approximately $10 million. The A&D sales run rate target of over $250 million by mid-2026, coupled with $20 million in annual sales from new energy programs starting in 2026, underscores significant growth potential. Full-year 2025 capital expenditures are estimated at $120 million, with $90 million funded by the U.S. government, supporting future capacity and efficiency.

Risks and Challenges

Despite the positive trajectory, Metallus faces several risks. Labor negotiations with the United Steelworkers (USW) Local 1123 remain ongoing, with the current contract extended to January 29, 2026, after a tentative agreement was rejected. This introduces uncertainty regarding potential labor and benefit cost increases. Global supply chain challenges, particularly in the automotive sector, could temporarily disrupt customer production, though management views these as timing issues that will eventually resolve. While tariffs generally benefit domestic demand, they can also lead to higher costs for certain offshore materials and operating supplies. The expiration of a long-term electrical energy contract in May 2025 has resulted in higher market prices for electricity, although Metallus has secured a two-year agreement for a large portion of its needs.

Conclusion

Metallus Inc. is strategically transforming into a highly specialized and technologically advanced producer within the U.S. steel industry. Its focused expansion into the high-growth Aerospace & Defense market, supported by substantial government funding and proprietary VAR/VIM steel capabilities, forms the core of its compelling investment thesis. Coupled with a strong balance sheet, a commitment to operational efficiency, and a favorable domestic trade environment, Metallus is well-positioned for sustainable profitable growth.

While near-term challenges such as seasonal slowdowns and ongoing labor negotiations warrant attention, the company's long-term outlook remains robust. The anticipated ramp-up in A&D sales, the introduction of high-value energy products, and the realization of significant operational savings are expected to drive enhanced financial performance in 2026 and beyond. Metallus's ability to leverage its specialized technology and customer-centric approach in critical, demanding applications provides a distinct competitive edge, making it an intriguing opportunity for discerning investors seeking exposure to a revitalized and specialized domestic steel sector.